CHICAGO — A seemingly minor disagreement over sandwich toppings escalated into a deadly confrontation at a Roseland restaurant last Tuesday, leaving two men dead and a community in shock.
The incident occurred around 4:10 p.m. at Momty’s Grill, located at 9 E. 111th Street, on Chicago’s South Side. Police say the dispute began when a customer became upset that the cheese on his sandwich order was incorrect.
The argument quickly intensified between the customer and a female employee. In an effort to diffuse the situation, the employee called her son to the restaurant for assistance. What followed turned fatal.
Altercation Escalates Into Fatal Gunfire
According to investigators, the employee’s son arrived shortly after the dispute began and was confronted by the customer and another man, later identified as Monte Potts, 34, and Dexter Williams, 38. Witnesses report that the son was punched and chased outside the establishment by the two men.
In response, the son allegedly pulled out a firearm and opened fire, striking both men. Potts suffered a gunshot wound to the back and was pronounced dead later that day at Advocate Christ Medical Center in Oak Lawn. Williams, who was shot in the head and arm, succumbed to his injuries the next day at the same hospital.
Shooter in Custody, Investigation Ongoing
The shooter, whose name has not been released, sustained minor injuries during the altercation and was taken to Roseland Community Hospital for treatment. He was later taken into police custody. As of the latest update, no formal charges have been filed.
Chicago Police Department officials stated that detectives from Area Two are investigating and that self-defense may be a factor in the case. Prosecutors are working closely with investigators to determine whether charges will be filed.
A Community Stunned by Tragedy
Locals who frequent Momty’s Grill describe it as a longstanding neighborhood spot known for casual comfort food and friendly staff. The restaurant remained closed for several days following the incident.
“It’s hard to believe something like this happened over a sandwich,” said Tyrone Nash, a resident who lives two blocks from the restaurant. “We’ve got to figure out how to de-escalate before things get this far.”
Many in Roseland are now calling for greater attention to conflict resolution and gun safety, as yet another routine outing turned tragic.
Do you think local restaurants and public spaces need better conflict prevention strategies? Have you ever seen minor disputes turn unexpectedly violent? Share your thoughts below.
